To Mr. Joe Clark – Farewell and fly high! Thank you for planting the seed of education in so many! “We sink, we swim, we rise, we fall – We meet our fate together.” – Mr. Clark ???????? pic.twitter.com/cui0juj5IP

— Lindsay Sharp (@LPSharpD300) December 30, 2020

Although his methods were hailed across the country, many Black teachers at the time and since then have come out harshly against the things Clark did while in charge, according to articles from Time and The Los Angeles Times.

The most controversial of his decisions, expelling children who sold drugs, fought, or had lackluster attendance, caused a significant backlash in his own community and among educators across the country.

Some criticized him for effectively discarding certain kids and others said his methods were only being allowed because most of the children at his school were Black. Many also lamented all of the kids who could have succeeded but were thrown out before they could get on the right track.

"We want to fix the schools, but you don't do that by seeing the kids as the enemy. Our role is to rescue and to be responsible. If the students were not poor Black children, Joe Clark would not be tolerated," Los Angeles Principal George McKenna told Time in 2001.

Although he criticized him, McKenna did say that administrators like Clark were forced to take drastic measures because of funding shortages and other societal ills that were not being addressed by the government.

Clark ardently defended all of his actions, routinely saying it was impossible for any student to learn in an environment rife with violence and drugs.

In a CNN interview at the time quoted by the Paterson Times, Clark said, "I must state forthrightly that I am a benevolent dictator.”

“I don’t just categorically extirpate young people out of school, but I am categorically emphatic that we cannot any longer condone hooliganism, aberrant behavior, deviant behavior in those schools. I’m convinced that young people, the vast majority, deserve the right to an environment that’s conducive to learning,” he added.

But others, including executive director of the New Jersey branch of the American Civil Liberties Union Edward Martone, said Clark's methods were offloading the students he threw out into other more dangerous situations.

"If every inner-city principal took the Joe Clark tack, they'd just throw one-third of their student body into the street. At best those kids are going to get minimum-wage jobs. At worst they're going to end up committing crimes and being incarcerated," Martone told Time.

The conversation around this tactic — throwing out or barring low scoring kids from attending a school — is facing renewed criticism now that charter schools have been caught doing the same thing.

Clark retired from the school in 1989 and moved to Florida. His two daughters are decorated Olympic athletes in track and field while his son is director of track and field and cross country at Stanford University.

In a statement to local news outlet ABC 7, Paterson superintendent of schools Eileen Shafer said the community was deeply saddened to hear about Clark's passing.

"Joe Clark left his indelible mark on public education by being fiercely devoted to the students in his care. He demanded more from his students because he believed they could achieve more than what was expected of them," she said.

"And with his bullhorn and baseball bat, Joe Clark courageously stood in the way of anyone who dared to try to lure a young person down the wrong path. Joe Clark was even the subject of a Hollywood movie. But in the end, it is the many lives Joe Clark influenced for the better that have become his greatest legacy," she added.

Joe-Clark

Get relevant content delivered to you once a week